+
From: bradley nitins <b.nitins@xxxxxxxxx>
+
Date: Fri, 18 Nov 2005 11:33:17 +1000
Hi All,
As i'm sure Michael is aware ' freedom of conscience' has a
peculiarly poignant relationship to English history, especially from
what as been termed the 'early modern period' onwards. I won't bore
both him and the rest of the list by launching into an explanation of
how it was deployed by English dissenters against the Anglican
establishment, and concomitantly by Parliamentarians against the
Monarchy, this is all very well travelled ground. What i would like
to point out- something that is far less known and appreciated- is
how this notion was equally deployed by the Monarchial Anglican
establishment themselves in service of their own ends. Thus i'm
wondering if Michael was aware that king James [Charle's the II's
successor] in April of 1687 issued his _Declaration for the Liberty
of Conscience_ a general indulgence of 'dissenters' of all
denominations, including Catholics! Needless to say its reception was
mixed. Thus, contained within this historical event, we are witness
how a particular 'ideological instrument', that of 'freedom of
conscience', which had reference primarily to a rather discrete
social configuration of historical individuals [Protestant
dissenters], was appropriated, reinterpreted, and redeployed by
another social configuration with exactly opposite interests, beliefs
and ends! This brings to mind Foucault's quote in _Nietzsche,
Genealogy and HIstory_ that: "if interpretation is the violent or
surreptitious appropriation of a system of rules, which in itself has
no essential meaning, in order to imposed a direction, to bend it to
a new will, to force its participation in a different game, and to
subject it to secondary rules, then the development of humanity is a
series of interpretations".
Bradley
[who is very glad that uni semester has finished and he can spare
time once again for pleasant intellectual procrastination]
"Of all writings I love only those which the writer writeth with his
blood. Write in blood, and thou shalt learn that blood is spirit"
Nietzsche. "Thus Spake Zarathustra".